Uiua, 22 bytes, score 4
⍜⇌'⊂@"⊂"&p-π\""+π
restricted set is &p-"
this would be much easier if the implicit stack printing didn't put quotes around strings, as it stands i could not get rid of &p, either -
or +
for offsetting the codepoints, or "
, $
, or @
and a lot of ⊂
s