#Pyth, 19 bytes

esDm@LQdtf!q#1.+TyU

Try it online here, or verify all the test cases at once here.

esDm@LQdtf!q#1.+TyUQ   Implicit: Q=eval(input())
                       Trailing Q inferred
                  UQ   Generate range [0-len(Q))
                 y     Take the powerset of the above
         f             Filter keep elements of the above, as T, using:
              .+T        Take differences of consecutive elements of T
           q#1           Keep those differences equal to 1
          !              Logical NOT - empty lists evaluate to true, populated ones to false
                       Result of the filter is those sets without consecutive numbers
        t              Drop the first element (empty set)
   m                   Map the remaining sets, as d, using:
     L d                 For each element of d...
    @ Q                  ... get the element in Q with that index
 sD                    Order the sets by their sum
e                      Take the last element, implicit print

Pyth, 19 bytes

esDm@LQdtf!q#1.+TyU

Try it online here, or verify all the test cases at once here.

esDm@LQdtf!q#1.+TyUQ   Implicit: Q=eval(input())
                       Trailing Q inferred
                  UQ   Generate range [0-len(Q))
                 y     Take the powerset of the above
         f             Filter keep elements of the above, as T, using:
              .+T        Take differences of consecutive elements of T
           q#1           Keep those differences equal to 1
          !              Logical NOT - empty lists evaluate to true, populated ones to false
                       Result of the filter is those sets without consecutive numbers
        t              Drop the first element (empty set)
   m                   Map the remaining sets, as d, using:
     L d                 For each element of d...
    @ Q                  ... get the element in Q with that index
 sD                    Order the sets by their sum
e                      Take the last element, implicit print

#Pyth, 19 bytes

esDm@LQdtf!q#1.+TyU

Try it online here, or verify all the test cases at once here.

#Pyth, 19 bytes

esDm@LQdtf!q#1.+TyU

Try it online here, or verify all the test cases at once here.

esDm@LQdtf!q#1.+TyUQ   Implicit: Q=eval(input())
                       Trailing Q inferred
                  UQ   Generate range [0-len(Q))
                 y     Take the powerset of the above
         f             Filter keep elements of the above, as T, using:
              .+T        Take differences of consecutive elements of T
           q#1           Keep those differences equal to 1
          !              Logical NOT - empty lists evaluate to true, populated ones to false
                       Result of the filter is those sets without consecutive numbers
        t              Drop the first element (empty set)
   m                   Map the remaining sets, as d, using:
     L d                 For each element of d...
    @ Q                  ... get the element in Q with that index
 sD                    Order the sets by their sum
e                      Take the last element, implicit print